David Beckham and Steven Gerrard. Two players lauded for their honesty and commitment on the field; for both club and country. These are not the players who come to mind when thinking about the conniving, dishonest side of football – usually associated with the ‘Jonny Foreigner’ likes of Cristiano Ronaldo or Didier Drogba. Those who saw Gerrard’s penalty win against Athletico Madrid, in last season’s Champions League, along with LA Galaxy fans, may wish to differ but the general perception remains one of integrity. Yet like so many who take the apparent high road both have shown themselves to ‘believe the myth’ and thus proved they are as fallible as any cheating diver.
Beckham has claimed that he wanted to “shake one of the guy’s hands” after calling an LA Galaxy fan out of the crowd. When the supporter, who was saying things that “wasn’t very nice”, accepted Beckham’s invitation and jumped from the stand, Beckham began to scale an advertising hoarding. Now exactly what Beckham would have done had he reached the fan we will never know since security stepped in well before the pair clashed, however it is fairly safe to assume, given the body language, neither man had hand shakes on his mind. If that was Beckham’s true intention why did he attempt the jump the advertising hoarding?
I have no problem with Beckham confronting, and taking issue, with someone who has been shouting obsenities at him – it is the bare faced lying to the general public afterwards which galls me. Just as the fan should have the stomach to stand by his statements, so Beckham should stand by his actions. At the very least he should not insult the intelligence of fans by fabricating such a ridiculous story about his intentions when calling the man down from the stand.
Now we get to the murkier issue of Steven Gerrard. He has been cleared of affray at Liverpool Crown Court today, even though there is clear CCTV footage of the Liverpool captain confronting then punching another man in a Southport bar. In court Gerrard stated that he was acting in self defence as he punched Marcus McGee three times without receiving a single blow himself. Gerrard’s co-defendant, who initially began the assault, elbowing Mr. McGee in the head, pleaded guilty to affray and is awaiting sentencing. In total six of Gerrard’s companions, including two Accrington Stanley players, are awaiting sentencing after pleading guilty to either affray or threatening behavior.
The disparity in the treatment between the superstar and his friends is striking. There is clear video evidence showing Steven Gerrard punching Marcus McGee yet he has been completely exonerated of any wrong doing! This is a legal issue more than anything else yet the point still stand that a superstar footballer can make as unbelievable a statement as he likes and yet he will be taken seriously.
Just as it is highly unlikely Beckham wanted to shake the hand of an abusive fan, it is equally as unlikely that after the first or second punch – or whilst being held back by friends – Gerrard believed he was defending himself. Yet both told the public these stories, and both, to some extent, were taken seriously.
That is not to say that these are generally violent or uncharitable men. On the contrary they are two of the most admirable footballers when it comes to helping others from their very privileged positions. Yet just because they have been charitable in other areas it should not grant them a ‘get out of jail free card’ when they slip up. There is a lack of humility, of honesty, in these players. Even with cameras documenting their actions both men are arrogant enough they feel they can re-write history with the most bizarre interpretations of the footage.
Fans should not expect players to be saints. They should however expect them to be able to admit a mistake, or at the very least not lie about it. To use the Football Association’s buzz word of last season, respect is what is lacking in the mindset of some professional sportsmen – to officials, referees and, in the worst cases to the fans who pay their wages.